CAMEL And The Business Of Bank Supervision
The Eastern Caribbean Central Bank (ECCB) Agreement Act 1983,
which established the ECCB, gave the Bank the authority to supervise
and regulate banking business on behalf of and in collaboration
with the eight member governments of the Eastern Caribbean Currency
Union.
As regulator, the ECCB’s role is to preserve the safety
and soundness of the banking system. In carrying out this
role, the ECCB monitors and evaluates the risk sensitivity
and risk management profiles of banks and other financial
institutions engaged in banking business. The ECCB also monitors
and evaluates the performance of these institutions by using
the CAMEL approach which assesses banks in
five principal areas namely; Capital Adequacy,
Asset Quality, Management
Soundness, Earnings and Liquidity.
Let us briefly examine these areas:
i. Capital Adequacy. Financial institutions
engaged in banking business are required by law to hold a
certain amount of capital, which should serve as a buffer
against losses.
ii. Asset Quality. – The solvency
risk of a financial institution often originates from the
quality of its asset portfolio. An indication of asset quality
is the ratio of non-performing credits (loans and advances
which are delinquent) to total credits. In the ECCU, the ECCB
stipulates an upper limit that this ratio should not exceed.
This stipulation is one of the measures designed to limit
the risks associated with credit extensions in order to minimise
the possibility of banks incurring substantial losses arising
from default. Defaults jeopardise the safety of the funds
placed by depositors and investors.
While the rule allows for banks and other institutions engaged
in banking business to absorb some losses, a high level of
diligence on the part of their administrators is required
in monitoring the institution’s exposure to bad debts,
and in their assessment of the level of credit risk posed
by each potential borrower prior to extending credit.
iii. Management Soundness – Sound management
is one of the most important pre-requisites for the strength
and growth of any financial institution. The availability
of sound procedures to limit and respond to the institution’s
exposure to risk, proper internal controls and audit systems
as well as competent staff and management are among the key
indicators of management quality.
iv. Earnings – A financial institution,
which has consistently demonstrated strong earnings and profitability,
provides a good indication of its ability to support present
and future operations. Furthermore, its earnings and profitability
determine its capacity to absorb losses, finance its expansion
and pay adequate dividends to shareholders. In the financial
industry, the most widely used indicator of earnings and profitability
is the Return on Assets (ROA).
v. Liquidity – Banks in their normal
course of business must hold a portion of their assets in
liquid form in order to meet the withdrawal demands of their
customers. Tight (low) liquidity is usually an indicator of
poor funds management. Presently all institutions licensed
to engage in banking business in the Eastern Caribbean Currency
Union are subject to a statutory liquidity requirement.
The ECCB conducts inspections to ensure that banks and other
financial institutions engaged in banking business adhere
to these requirements. Application of CAMEL ratings allows
the ECCB to examine the financial soundness of these institutions.
A financial institution in receipt of a less than satisfactory
CAMEL rating is closely monitored by the ECCB. The ECCB may
then enter into a Letter of Commitment or a Memorandum of
Understanding with the institution, specifying targets that
need to be achieved over a period of time in order to improve
its financial soundness.
Click here
for the printer friendly version
|